October 2, 2009
In this issue...
- Dodd Wants Agency Consolidation, Taking Fed and FDIC Out of Supervision
- FDIC Proposes Prepayment of Assessments
- FDIC Provides Assessment Q&A
- Chairman Frank Revises Consumer Protection Bill
- Committee Holds Hearing on Proposed GAO Audit of Federal Reserve
- Agencies Propose Guidance on Correspondent Risks
- Georgian Bank Closed; S.C. Bank Takes Over
- Minneapolis Fed Taps New President
- Around the States
- Around The Agencies
- Upcoming Events
- Closing Comment
CSBS Website Links

CSBS Home
Calendar of Events
REGBYTES
Profile
Contact Us
SRR Home
NMLS Home

Upcoming Events
Model Examination Guidelines User School (Web-based), October, November & December sessions open for registration:  Developed by AARMR and CSBS, this school is designed to assist mortgage regulators and mortgage industry compliance personnel implement the examination procedures for the Guidance on Nontraditional Mortgage Product Risks (Guidance) and the Statement on Subprime Mortgage Lending (Statement).
Online Courses Beginning October 5: Asset Liability Management II, Fraud Identification Training, IT Systems Examination, Real Estate Appraisal Review, Money Service Business Examiner Course.
Examiner Education Forum, November 2-4, 2009, Charleston, SC:  A forum for banking department training directors to discuss trends and needs in examiner training.
Practical Commercial Credit Skills for Examiners, November 16-17, 2009, Frankfort, KY:  A two day program designed for experienced bank examiners for the purpose of enhancing their abilities to analyze and communicate credit-risk issues associated with commercial loans.
Supervisors Symposium, December 7-11, 2009, Washington, DC:  Bankers Advisory Board meeting, CSBS Board Meeting and Supervisors Symposium.
October 2, 2009
"I'm not bossy. I just know what you should (not) be doing.” – Bumper Sticker

This week, the U.S. Department of Transportation held a two-day summit to point out the dangers of distracted driving. In our minds, it should be a no-brainer that a driver should not be text-messaging behind the wheel. However, we seem to have a texting epidemic going on and getting worse. Quite frankly, we are astonished to see people going down the highway at 60 mph, their thumbs flying over the keyboards on their "handheld mobile devices", their eyes not on the road at all. A few days ago, we heard a radio interview with a teenage girl who had two serious accidents while text-messaging while driving. She actually admitted being addicted to the practice.  The Transportation Department estimates that 6,000 people were killed in distracted driving accidents last year, not only in car wrecks but also in public transportation accidents. Legislation is making the rounds on Capitol Hill to encourage states to pass laws making texting or e-mailing while driving illegal. But such a law in the District of Columbia is ignored as much as it's obeyed. Laws are well and good, but common sense would be better. As Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) so aptly stated, "No text message is so urgent that it's worth dying over."


Dodd Wants Agency Consolidation, Taking Fed and FDIC Out of Supervision
Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.) continued to push for consolidation of federal regulators as a part of the industry reform package.

“Last week I suggested further consolidation of bank regulators would make a lot of sense.  We could combine the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Office of Thrift Supervision while transferring bank supervision authorities from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation and the Federal Reserve, leaving them to focus on their core functions.”

However, the chairman also called for the continuation of the dual banking system. At a hearing on Tuesday, Dodd also recognized the important role played by community banks. “Community banks did not cause this crisis, and they should not have to bear the cost or burden of increased regulation necessitated by others. Regulation should be based on risk -- community banks do not present the same type of supervisory challenges their large counterparts do,” he said.

CSBS opposes regulatory consolidation as Sen. Dodd suggests.

President and CEO Neil Milner stated,  “Regulatory consolidation leads to industry consolidation. A monolithic regulator would threaten economic growth and stability by undoing the diversity of the banking industry.  The natural tendency of a single financial regulator would be to tailor its regulatory policies and supervisory approach to its largest institutions, disadvantaging smaller institutions, most which are state-chartered.  Regulatory consolidation does nothing to address our number one risk – too big to fail.”

Sen. Dodd’s statement


FDIC Proposes Prepayment of Assessments
The FDIC on Tuesday issued a proposal to require banks to prepay their estimated quarterly risk-based assessments for the fourth quarter of 2009 and for all of 2010, 2011 and 2012 to bolster the Deposit Insurance Fund. FDIC estimated that the total prepaid assessments collected would be approximately $45 billion. The FDIC Board also voted to adopt a uniform three-basis point increase in assessment rates effective on Jan. 1, 2011, and extend the restoration period from seven to eight years. FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair said the industry has the liquidity to prepay assessments with banks holding more than $1.3 trillion in liquid balances as of June 30. FDIC said this approach should have less effect on bank lending than a one-time special assessment. While prepaid assessments would be mandatory for all institutions, FDIC could exempt an institution from the requirement if would affect the safety and soundness of the institution. The proposal also would allow institutions to request exemption from payment under certain circumstances. The proposal has a 30-day comment period. For more information, see news release.


FDIC Provides Assessment Q&A
FDIC on Wednesday published a question and answer document on its proposal to replenish the Deposit Insurance Fund by having insured institutions prepay their assessments. The proposal would require banks to prepay their estimated quarterly risk-based assessments for the fourth quarter of 2009 and for all of 2010, 2011 and 2012 to bolster the Deposit Insurance Fund. FDIC estimated that the total prepaid assessments collected would be approximately $45 billion. In the document, FDIC explained that it wanted to reserve borrowing from Treasury for emergencies, when unforeseen events require an unexpected large cash outflow. FDIC said the Deposit Insurance Fund’s current liquidity needs do not represent an emergency and can be planned for and met by industry resources. To account for the prepayments, FDIC explained that each institution would record the entire amount of its prepaid assessment as a prepaid expense (an asset) as of Dec. 30, 2009, the date the payment would be made. As of Dec. 31, 2009, and each quarter thereafter, each institution would record an expense (charge to earnings) for its regular quarterly assessment and an offsetting credit to the prepaid assessment until the asset is exhausted. FDIC said it is projecting that the Deposit Insurance Fund will incur approximately $100 billion in failure costs over the period 2009 through 2013. See FAQs


Chairman Frank Revises Consumer Protection Bill
Prior to Wednesday's hearing to gather additional viewpoints on the proposed Consumer Financial Protection Agency (CFPA), House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank (D-Mass.) released revised draft legislation (H.R. 3126) reflecting a number of changes in response to concerns raised by industry and consumer groups. CSBS has analyzed the revised bill, noting provisions of interest to state bank regulators. The revised legislation changes the structure of the agency from a five person board to a single director, advised by an oversight board to include the Fed, FDIC, national bank supervisor, NCUA, FTC, HUD, and state representation by the chair of the FFIEC State Liaison Committee. In  his revised bill, Chairman Frank inserted specific exemptions for certain types of non-financial firms such as retailers, accountants, tax preparation services, real estate brokers and agents, etc. He also added registration requirements for nonbanks that provide consumer financial products. The revised bill also changes funding requirements from appropriations and fees and other assessments to having the Federal Reserve transfer 10 percent of total expenses and sets up separate funds within Treasury to cover CFPA expenses for banks vs. nonbanks. He also set up a dispute resolution mechanism and removed the original requirement that mandated financial institutions providers to offer "plain vanilla" products. The revised bill maintains the original version's elimination of federal preemption of state consumer protection laws and allows states to go beyond federal standards. CSBS's support of the measure is contingent on these provisions (elimination of federal preemption and preservation of the "floor not ceiling" provisions) and maintaining a significant role for state regulators in terms of coordination and consultation in rulemaking and examinations.  Additionally, CSBS supports examination by the prudential regulator.  Chairman Frank has indicated he plans to mark up the bill the week of October 12.


Committee Holds Hearing on Proposed GAO Audit of Federal Reserve
The House Financial Services Committee convened last Friday for a hearing on H.R. 1207. the Federal Reserve Transparency Act of 2009. The bill, sponsored by Rep. Ron Paul (R-Texas) calls for a full and complete audit of the Federal Reserve by the Government Accountability Office, reported to Congress by the end of 2010. The Federal Reserve Board's General Counsel Scott Alvarez testified at Friday's hearing, noting that a wide range of Federal Reserve policies and functions currently are subject to GAO audit. However, he spoke in opposition to efforts that would grant the GAO authority to audit the monetary policy and related activities. "We think that monetary policy must be done in an independent manner and believe it is most effective without second guessing," Alvarez said. "If the bill were passed today we are concerned that there would be loss of confidence by investors and the public which would hurt our ability to make policy, to ensure price stability and maximize employment." Alvarez noted that since the System began operations in 1924, the Federal Reserve has published its balance sheets every week, showing the assets and liabilities of the Reserve Banks, both individually and on a consolidated basis. Also, the Federal Open Market Committee releases a statement describing its monetary policy decisions immediately after each regularly scheduled meeting and publishes detailed minutes of each meeting three weeks later. Alvarez also discussed enhanced efforts to publish information about the Fed's policy programs and financial activities. "The Congress purposefully -- and with good reason -- chose to exclude from GAO review only two highly sensitive areas: one is monetary policy deliberations, decisions, and actions, including open market and discount window operations; and the other is Federal Reserve transactions for or with foreign central banks, foreign governments, and public international financing organizations...to ensure that the Federal Reserve Board could 'independently conduct the nation's monetary policy.' " The legislation has garnered 295 cosponsors this session. Committee Chairman Barney Frank (D-Mass.) said that a version of H.R. 1207 would be included in the regulatory reform legislation coming out of the Financial Services Committee. For more information, see testimony


Agencies Propose Guidance on Correspondent Risks
The federal banking agencies issued proposed guidance on their expectations for identifying, monitoring, managing and performing due diligence for correspondent concentration risks. The regulators – FDIC, the Federal Reserve, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and the Office of Thrift Supervision -- generally have considered credit exposures greater than 25 percent of Tier 1 capital as concentrations, while funding exposures as low as 5 percent of an institution's total liabilities could be considered a concentration. The supplemental guidance calls for management to: adopt procedures for identifying an institution's aggregate credit and funding exposures to other institutions and their affiliates; specify what information, ratios or trends will be reviewed for each correspondent; set prudent correspondent concentration limits, establish ranges or tolerances for each factor being monitored, and develop plans for managing risks when these limits, ranges or tolerances are met or exceeded, either individually or collectively; and conduct an independent analysis before entering into any credit or funding transactions with another financial institution. The comment deadline is Oct. 26. See notice in the Federal Register


Georgian Bank Closed; S.C. Bank Takes Over
The Georgia Department of Banking and Finance closed Georgian Bank, Atlanta, on Friday and appointed FDIC as receiver. FDIC entered into a purchase agreement with First Citizens Bank and Trust Co., Inc., Columbia, S.C., to assume all of the deposits and all of the assets of the failed bank. Georgian Bank had total assets of $2 billion and total deposits of approximately $2 billion. FDIC and First Citizens Bank entered into a loss-share transaction on approximately $2 billion of Georgian Bank's assets.  Georgian Bank is the 95th bank to fail this year and the 19th in Georgia.  Read more


Minneapolis Fed Taps New President
The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis announced that Dr. Naryana Kocherlakota will be its next president and chief executive officer effective Oct. 8. He replaces Gary Stern, who announced his retirement earlier this year. Kocherlakota is currently a professor of economics at the University of Minnesota and a consultant to the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Previously, he served as a professor of economics at Stanford University, an associate professor at the University of Iowa and an assistant professor at Northwestern University. Kocherlakota has an A.B. in mathematics from Princeton and received his Ph.D. in economics from the University of Chicago. He has published more than 30 articles in academic journals. The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis is responsible for the Ninth Federal Reserve District, which includes Montana, North and South Dakota, Minnesota, northwestern Wisconsin and the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Kocherlakota will serve on the Federal Open Market Committee. For more information see announcement


Around the States
Connecticut: Connecticut State Banking Commissioner Howard Pitkin issued a schedule of the maximum fees that a debt negotiator may legally charge for specific services. The new law, An Act Concerning Consumer Credit Licensees, makes a number of changes in consumer credit licensees and goes into effect on Oct. 1. The law expands the definition of a licensed debt adjuster to include for-profit entities. The definition of debt negotiation includes debt settlement, foreclosure rescue and short sales. The law creates a new license for debt negotiators that imposes the same licensing regime as debt adjusters for application procedures, requirements and enforcement. The law also imposes additional consumer protection safeguards for all debt adjusters. The fees structure allows a one-time, initial fee of up to $50, a monthly service fee of up to $8 for each creditor listed in the debt negotiation service contract with a cap of $40; and an aggregate fee cap of 10 percent of the consumer’s debt reduction for unsecured debt and a $500 cap for secured debt. For more information, see the department’s news release

Idaho: Idaho State Treasurer Ron Crane is hosting a free financial conference for women on Oct. 3 in Boise, said Idaho Department of Finance Director Gavin Gee. The Smart Women, Smart Money — Idaho Every Woman’s Financial Conference is an annual event in the state and aims to help women increase their financial knowledge and skills. The meeting provides interactive workshops, free financial education materials, motivational presentations, and continuing education credits. Gee said the Idaho Department of Finance will have a workshop presenter at the conference to address how to prevent home foreclosures and preserve credit standings. The department’s booth will have books, brochures and pamphlets available with information about the basics of saving and investing, mortgages, credit cards, credit scoring, foreclosure avoidance resources, reverse mortgages, identity theft, and avoiding investment and financial fraud. For more information, see announcement


Around The Agencies
FDIC: The FDIC reminded bankers of foreclosure provisions in the Helping Families Save Their Homes Act that became law in May. Under the law, a tenant must receive a 90-day notice before being evicted as the result of a foreclosure. With some exceptions, the law requires that in the event of foreclosure, existing leases for renters should be honored to the end of the term of their leases. The exceptions are for tenants without leases, tenants with leases terminable at will under state law, or where the owners acquiring the properties will occupy them as primary residences. In these cases, the tenants must receive notices to vacate the properties 90 days or more in advance. FDIC said the law does not affect the requirements of any state or local law that provides longer time periods or other additional protections for tenants. The law applies to foreclosures after May 20. While the law did not authorize any agency to write regulations, FDIC said its examiners will monitor and enforce compliance with the requirements in the same manner as other consumer protection laws and regulations. See Financial Institution Letter

Federal Reserve: The Federal Reserve on Tuesday proposed rules to protect credit card consumers from costly practices that are prohibited by the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act of 2009. Among other things, the proposal would: prohibit most increases in rates during the first year after accounts are opened and increases in rates that apply to existing credit card balances; prohibit creditors from issuing a credit card to a consumer who is under the age of 21 unless the consumer has the ability to make the required payments or obtains the signature of a parent or other cosigner with the ability to do so; require creditors to obtain a consumer's consent before charging fees for transactions that exceed the credit limit; limit high fees associated with subprime credit cards; ban creditors from using the "two cycle" billing method to impose interest charges; and prohibit creditors from allocating payments in ways that maximize interest charges. The changes will go into effect on Feb. 22, 2010. The remaining provisions of the credit card law go into effect on Aug. 22, 2010. The proposal has a 30-day comment period. See proposal

Federal Reserve: The Federal Reserve revised the rates and conditions under which a government agency must reimburse a financial institution for costs incurred in producing customer financial records under the Right to Financial Privacy Act. The revisions to Regulation S go into effect on Jan. 1, 2010. One of the most significant changes allows a substantial increase in personal fees for searching and processing document requests. The amendments also encourage electronic document productions by prohibiting a $0.25 per page fee to be charged by a financial institution for printing electronically stored information unless the requesting agency consents. The amended regulation also includes a mechanism to update labor rates automatically every three years. See Final rule


Upcoming Events
October 6 - The House Financial Services Committee will hold a hearing on: "Capital Markets Regulatory Reform: Strengthening Investor Protection, Enhancing Oversight of Private Pools of Capital, and Creating a National Insurance Office." - 10 a.m., 2128 Rayburn House Office Building.

October 7 - The House Financial Services Committee will hold a hearing on reform of the over-the-counter derivatives market. - 10 a.m., 2128 Rayburn House Office Building.

October 7 - The Senate Banking Committee will hold a hearing on “Securitization of Assets: Problems and Solutions.” - 2:30 p.m., 538 Dirksen Senate Office Building.

October 8 -  The House Financial Services Committee will hold a hearing on: “H.R. 2382, the Credit Card Interchange Fees Act of 2009 and H.R. 3639, the Expedited CARD Reform for Consumers Act of 2009.” - 10 a.m., 2128 Rayburn House Office Building.

October 8 - The House Financial Services Subcommittee on Housing and Community Opportunity will hold a hearing on “The Future of the Federal Housing Administration’s Capital Reserves: Assumptions, Predictions and Implications for Homebuyers.” - 2 p.m., 2128 Rayburn House Office Building.


Closing Comment
"State governments have plenty to do these days without looking for ways to inhibit the activities of national banks. Rather than pointing fingers over who should or should not protect people, we should redouble our efforts at state/federal cooperation and work together to develop the type of national standards that states would rarely need to exceed." - New York Superintendent of Banks Richard Neiman and North Carolina Commissioner of Banks Joseph A. Smith Jr., from a letter to the editor in Wednesday's Wall Street Journal.


Mary White, Editor
Teresa Dean, Contributing Writer