Skip to main content

FDIC Regulation Can Cause a Liquidity Crunch for Smaller Banks

In a comment letter sent today to the FDIC, CSBS suggested changes to the regulatory treatment of brokered deposits and deposit interest cap methodology.

Brokered deposits can be a source of supplemental funding for banks in rural areas or markets that lack local deposits to meet community needs and are a critical credit to agriculture customers and small businesses. However, the FDIC has generally viewed brokered deposit waivers as increasing the risk to the Deposit Insurance Fund. 

State regulators have long been concerned that the current supervisory approach can cause a liquidity crunch for already struggling banks. If a bank falls under the prompt corrective action (PCA) framework, it is immediately prohibited from renewing or issuing brokered deposits. This creates an unnecessary strain on liquidity, destabilizes the institution and increases the risk to the Deposit insurance Fund.

If a bank triggers PCA by falling below “well capitalized,” state regulators recommend it should be able to reduce its brokered deposits over time. Rather than increasing the risk to the deposit insurance fund, a more gradual approach lowers the risk by placing the bank on a “glide path” for easing their dependence on brokered deposits. CSBS recommends that banks be allowed to develop a plan to unwind their brokered deposit positions over 12 to 24 months, which would avoid a liquidity crunch as the bank works to enhance capital and reduce its risk profile. 

CSBS also recommended changing how the national interest cap is determined to account for fluctuating interest rates. Under the current methodology, banks subject to rate restrictions are unable to reasonably compete for deposits. One option recommended by CSBS would generally allow for a higher rate cap in a falling rate environment, while another recommended alternative would allow for a higher rate cap in a rising rate environment.

The FDIC asked for feedback on its supervision of brokered deposits in an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking issued in December. 

Recent Blog Posts

Blog post
Community bankers judge the balance of risks to 2020 economic growth to be weighted more to the downside in the most recent CBSI. CSBS Senior Economist Tom Siems breaks down the results by region and compares them to professional economists.
Feb 12, 2020
Blog post
CSBS Senior Economist Thomas Siems examines why the outlook for profitability dropped for some community banks in the latest Community Bank Sentiment Index.
Feb 6, 2020
Blog post
The CSBS Education Foundation is awarding graduate school of banking scholarships to three outstanding state regulators who have demonstrated excellence in their careers.
Jan 27, 2020
Blog post
CSBS Senior Economist Tom Siems examines wholesale funding strategy findings from the CSBS National Survey of Community Banks.
Jan 22, 2020
exit